[article] Irish Rail are investigating after a door lock on one of its carriage
 

http://www.independent.ie/irish-news...-34394362.html

Given that drivers randomly respect the stop boards at stations it was only a matter of time before something like this happened

While in this case it's a safety issue, this is is one of those things that is a mystery as to why they can't get right. Stopping in the right place is one of those little things that could make such a difference to the passenger experience.

It is a right pain to unnecessarily have to walk an extra four car-lengths up a windy dark platform with the rail pouring down on a winter night. It is far worse for people with restricted mobility. How much effort is it to stop the train within 10 foot of any given stop.

I've seen a few times when the Japanese sets are opened/unlocked a couple of seconds before the train has come to a complete halt.

Thats completely fine under the rules

Common sense and not rules dictate that train should be stopped before doors open.

Safety rule book allows the doors to be release below 3kph

Try the Paris metro when the train could be still moving at a fair pace before stopping

Extreme safety dictates that the doors can't be opened until the train is stopped and brakes are locked. This would slow operations down and make journey times less competitive so more people would drive which would result in an overall increase in road deaths.

Back in the days of slam doors one or two people were killed every year falling out of trains which were probably mostly suicides so the situation nowadays is vastly improved.

I can remember as a student seeing people regularly jumping out of the Sligo train at the short down platform at Edgeworthstown because it use to take about 5 minutes to work your way up the overcrowded 1810 service.

Not to go to off topic but what system does Luas have, the doors ore unlocked (lights indicate anyway) before the tram stops however they don't actually open until it's stopped.

luas always stops first from my experiance.

Its usually driver specific.